McCurdy's Comedy Theatre Concerts 2025

Lots of big name shows! Service was good, a variety of food and drinks offered. Headliner was hilarious, opening act was funny too. So happy to have such a great local place!

Let's first say we had a ball. The 3 comedians we saw were pretty funny. Comedy shows are so hit and miss but this was a win show (for us). There is a 2 product purchase for each guest (purchases at the bar do not count towards minimum). Just FYI. We had 2 drinks off the cocktail menu and both were good. (Crystal blue lemondrop and I can't remember the other drink and my pic blurry...sorry) We stop for food prior to the show so we can't comment towards that. Prices were reasonable. The downfall for us was the seating arrangements. Cramped. Sit with people not in your party. Plenty of open tables in back so not sure why they didn't spread us out more (assigned seating). Some people sat in what looked like bus rows.... others similar to stand seating.... but with chairs. You are just sitting on top of one another and for that.... I probably wouldn't return unless seating changed. But that's my preference.

It’s a cool place to see some really great comedians. However, the bar area is so unbelievably cramped, you’re pretty much crammed in like sardines. If you’re not a people person, arrive a little later. Also, I really wished they would clean a little better, I can’t absolutely know for sure, but three days after attending one of the shows, I came down with the stomach flu. While this may or may not be due to cleanliness; it’s one of those things that really makes me apprehensive to attend the shows in the future. The comedy itself is outstanding and filled with a lot of fun. Les is great and very interactive with the crowd which is appreciated. I just wished you weren’t so compacted into an area sitting like you would on public transit. The drinks are great and I would highly recommend the blues brother’s drink. Oh, when you arrive in the bar area before sitting, the bartenders also say the two drink minimum doesn’t apply. So you can either arrive later or choose to have a drink at the bar. For the most part, it’s a nice spot with good service, great comedy, and a piece of Sarasota that shines pretty well.

I love this comedy club. I've been there 3 or 4 times in the past year. The staff is great service is quick and the food for snacking and drinking it's another plus. Now let's talk about the comedians, all of them are great they got top-notch headliners that are funny and all categories. I personally like the later show than the earlier show. It depends on the crowd you're looking for. I was there on Friday night and the opening was Les. He knows how to get the crowd ready for the comedian then after that the headliner comes in perfect. If you're visiting in town and want to get a great laughed stop by if you're a local you already know this place and I'm sure you're visiting a lot.

The comedians were amazing! But the staff really soured the mood. First we were rushed through the doors to our seats. Our waiter wanted us to all be on one check, we told him separate. 1 person in our group was ignored and, only received drinks through the bar area. When we got our checks they were all mixed up, and when getting them corrected, they were messed up even more. We had extra food added onto our bills that we had to get taken off. We ended up getting frustrated and paid for what we had on our bill. And when done we were brought another tab that had an appetizer and a drink on it that the waiter said was open, but at that point we told him we aren't paying, considering a couple of us ended up paying for stuff we didn't have. All in all the service was terrible. It really damped the experience and took away from some of the enjoyment of the comics on stage. I suggest looking for another place to watch a comedic act instead of there.